Hi, Leslie. This is really beautiful and working quite well. I actually love the form (with the lines the long line dividing) and I think
you should keep it (if you can add some white space like I have done.). To me
it doesn’t seem finished (a short braid) I want to hear more…more about your
mother and her death and the loss of the house. I don’t think it needs to be
too much longer maybe just a few more sections. Right now the piece seems to be
so much about femininity, mothers/daughters and clothing/ representation – what
is expected of women. I’d perhaps like to see something about being 52 and
having long hair (people say women of a certain age shouldn’t have long hair)
or a scene of you now braiding your hair. Another possibility: introducing
something about braids not personal…ie historical, a fact, famous women with
braids, etc. Not sure you want to go in this direction. This piece also seems
to be about economics/poverty of a certain kind. I would love that to come out
a little bit more as well. You have such a beautiful light touch here. The
details are really stunning. I love the stool with the found hairs. It reminds
me of that Jack Gilbert poem “Married” Do you know it? Here it is:
Married, Jack Gilbert
I came back from the funeral and crawled
around the apartment, crying hard,
searching for my wife’s hair.
For two months got them from the drain,
from the vacuum cleaner, under the refrigerator,
and off the clothes in the closet.
But after other Japanese women came,
there was no way to be sure which were
hers, and I stopped. A year later,
repotting Michiko’s avocado, I find
a long black hair tangled in the dirt.
*
(Essay 2)
Dear
Leslie,
It is
difficult to write about illness. I think you are off to a good start however.
My main comment is: keep going, get a draft out. Not sure if you want this to
be a lyric essay or just a personal essay – doesn’t really matter. I do think
you should pick one pov and stick with it. For some reason the second person is
working better for me/your language it seems. I love the last paragraph and
would love it to come a bit sooner in the piece. You are really on the right
track with that. I am wondering if you’ve read Megan ORourk’s piece in the New
Yorker about her immune-deficiency disease? It’s a great piece because it’s
kind of what you are writing about – a complicated illness that is difficult to
explain or understand. Check it out if you have time: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2013/08/26/130826fa_fact_orourke
As with
your other piece, please keep going. best, Sarah
No comments:
Post a Comment